There Is No Pain, You Are Receding
Posted by spritzophrenia on October 1, 2010
Doesn’t Genesis teach there was no pain and suffering until the fall, and therefore evolution cannot have been the mechanism?
Christians, Jews and to a lesser extent Muslims, all take their origin story from Genesis. At a particular point in the tale the human race is flourishing and then everything goes wrong. Humans make Promethean choices that separate them from God, and like all choices there are consequences, much like choosing to jump from a cliff. Christians call this “the fall”.
If you’re not familiar, here’s the whole passage. Among other things, in verse 16,
In a literal interpretation— the approach anti-evolutionists normally favour— this clearly implies pain before the fall. Note the phrase “greatly increase”. In other words, there was pain before the human representatives made their choice, it just wasn’t so bad. On a literal interpretation, pain was around even in Eden.
And that’s really the only point I want to make today.
By the way, according to Galileo Goes to Jail, and Other Myths about Science and Religion from my public library, the church did NOT oppose anesthesia in childbirth based on passages like these. I also noticed that male domination (the husband ruling over the woman) only came in AFTER the fall. Take that, “women must submit to men” theology. Gee, maybe literalist interpretations of the Torah aren’t so bad after all? (Noting my post suggesting this whole section, like much of early Genesis, appears to be poetic in form, and reading those sections ‘literally’ is probably a mistake.)
There are some people who rather enjoy a bit of pain (see below).
More on the problem of pain tomorrow
Why not subscribe to my blog? (Top Left)
Depeche Mode sing Strange Love:
I give in, to sin…
Will you take the pain… I give to you?
Pain, will you return it?
Also check out the great
Pain and Suffering remix (Replicant tribute)
Anyone like to guess the where the title of today’s post comes from?
How do you think about physical pain and the meaning of life?
Please share this article: